COMMUNITY IN CONSERVATION
NORTH AMERICA
GENERAL AGRICULTURE FOREST TENURE MARINE FISHERIES
PASTORAL PROTECTED AREAS WILDLIFE
GENERAL
Anonymous
(1996). “Special issue: environmental conflict.” Sociological Perspectives
39: 211-331.
A special issue on environmental
conflict in the U.S. Topics discussed
include science in environmental conflicts; the impact of race on environmental
quality; the experience of citizen group participants in alternative dispute
resolution processes; ecological postmodern praxis in radical environmentalist
identities; the demise of community and ecology in the Pacific Northwest;
mediation of environmental conflicts in Hawaii; and the systemic and anti
systemic forces in the battle for the preservation of the Brazilian Amazon rain
forest. (Journal)
Berneshawi,
S (1997). “Resource management and the Mi'kmaq Nation.” Canadian Journal of
Native Studies 17(1): 115-148.
Chance,
N and E Andreeva (1995). “Sustainability, equity, and natural-resource
development in northwest Siberia and arctic Alaska.” Human Ecology 23(2): 217-240.
Today, the search for new energy
sources continues unabated throughout the North. At the same time, scientists
are increasingly concerned over the degradation of the Arctic and sub-Arctic
environment stemming from fossil fuel and other large-scale energy projects
already underway. Similar apprehensions are expressed by indigenous peoples who
have often suffered from the impact of such development. While the most
dramatic evidence of environmental devastation and social disruption is found
in the Russian North serious problems are by no means confined to that area
alone. Nor are these negative effects necessarily limited to the borders of the
country in which they originated. Indeed, the deleterious environmental impact
of our global industrial economy has become sufficiently profound that social
analysts are beginning to ask whether development strategies that cause such
harm to the Arctic and sub-Arctic region should continue; and if not, what
should replace them. This article addresses these issues as they relate to
questions of sustainability, equity, political empowerment and human rights in
northwest Siberia and northern North America (Journal)
Cronon,
W (1992). “A place for stories: nature, history and narrative.” Journal of
American History March: 1347-1376.
Dowie,
M (1992). “The new face of environmentalism.” Utne Reader Jul/Aug(52): 1048.
Durning,
AB (1989). “Grass-roots groups are our best hope for global prosperity and
ecology.” Utne Reader July/Aug(34): 408.
Eikeland,
PO (1994). “US environmental NGOs: new strategies for new environmental
problems?” The Journal of Social, Political and Studies 19(3): 259(227).
Environmental non-governmental
organizations (NGOs) no longer limit themselves to merely criticizing
government policies, but play an active political role by implementing
differing strategies such as
influencing the government through public pressure and conflict/cooperation
with industry. Major environmental NGOs include the Environmental Defense Fund,
the World Resources Institute and the International Institute for Energy Conservation. Such NGOs seek to find
solutions to environmental problems
such as the conservation of natural
resources and the control of pollution at national and global levels, the scope and complexity of which
are increasing rapidly. (Econlit)
Flanders,
N (1998). “Native American sovereignty and natural resource management.” Human Ecology 26(3): 425-449.
The relationship between Native
Americans and the Euro-American settlers has evolved from the latter seeking to
end the separate identity of the former to one in which the U.S. government
uses Native rights to control large-scale resource problems. This new
relationship arose out of a need to control water in Western states for
irrigation, but has expanded into other areas. The Navajo sheep reductions of
the 1930s and 1940s may be seen as an instance of this relationship. Concerns
about siltation behind the Hoover Dam justified a program that dramatically
transformed the Navajo economy. A second case concerns conflict over a caribou
herd in northwestern Alaska. The conflict eventually led to the Federal
government taking management of fish and game on Federal lands back from the
state government. Both these cases show the development of a technocracy, based
on Federal trusteeship over Native resources, concerned with the control of
nature similar to that observed in Wittfogel's writings on Chinese irrigation
(Journal)
Gibson,
C and T Koontz (1998). “When "community" is not enough: institutions
and values in community-based forest management in southern Indiana.” Human
Ecology 26(4): 621-647.
Community-based management is
increasingly viewed as the most appropriate arrangement for promoting
sustainable development of naturalresources, A common assumption is that the
values of community members, often assumed to be homogeneous, foster successful
outcomes. However analysts often treat
these values and their homogeneity as exogenous factors, ignoring the community's
potential role in managing members' values. This study of community-based
forest management in two southern Indiana sites examines how the members of the
two communities created institutions to screen, maintain, and defend their
values. Analysis reveals that different institutions shaped members'
preferences and led to different levels of community stability, conflict
management, and natural resource condition. We argue that
understandingcommunity-based management processes and outcomes requires careful
attention to how institutions facilitate or hamper theconstruction of community
members' values. (Journal)
Gottesfeld,
L (1994). “Aboriginal burning for vegetation management in Northwest
British-Columbia.” Human Ecology 22(2): 171-188.
The Gitksan and Wet'suwet'en
peoples of northwest British Columbia occupy the upper drainage of the Skeena
River and the western headwaters of the Fraser River. They live in a region of
diverse topography, vegetation, and climate. Berry patch burning was the most important
traditional vegetation manipulation. Black huckleberry and lowbush blueberry
patches were burned to stimulate growth of new stems and production of berries,
while preventing invasion by other shrub species and conifers. Maintenance of
berry patches by burning was discontinued in the 1930s and 1940s because of
fire suppression by the British Columbia Forest Service. Spring burning on
south facing slopes, village sites, and garden sites was also practiced, and
continues to the present. It occurs in aspen, pine, or grass dominated seral
communities, or cottonwood floodplain forest, and is intended to control brush
and encourage growth of grass. (SSCI)
Gottesfeld,
L (1994). “Conservation, territory, and traditional beliefs: An analysis of
Gitksan and Wetsuweten subsistence, Northwest British-Columbia, Canada.” Human
Ecology 22(4): 443-465.
Aspects of the culture, resource
exploitation and beliefs of the Gitksan and Wet'suwet'en peoples of
northwestern British Columbia are examined to explore the relationship of their
cultural practices, land tenure, and beliefs to resource conservation.
Traditional Gitksan and Wet'suwet'en practices and beliefs contain a number of
elements which acted to promote conservation, including territoriality,
prescribed burning, and proscription of waste, and other elements which are
more difficult to reconcile with a biological model of conservation. The
concept of humans as part of the natural world, and the requirement for respect
for all natural entities are the fundamental to mediating human interactions
with other species in the Gitksan and Wet'suwet'en cultures. (Journal)
Hahn, S
(1982). “Hunting, fishing, and foraging: common rights and class relations in
the Postbellum South.” Radical History Review 26: 37-64.
Johnson,
K (1993). “Reconciling rural communities and resource conservation.” Environment 35: 16-20+.
Over the past several years, more and more projects have been
launched in the Pacific Northwest that try to reconcile the goals of economic
vitality and environmental stewardship in rural communities. The more promising initiatives do not try to
reach an elusive "balance" between economy and environment, which
leaves habitats half protected, rural economies weakened, and personal
principles compromised. Instead, they
try to create synergies ways that
economic activity can promote a healthy environment and that healthy ecosystems
can enrich their inhabitants both economically and otherwise. Although new, many of the projects offer
important lessons to practitioners and policymakers in the field. The Clinton administration's Forest Plan for
a Sustainable Economy and a Sustainable Environment is discussed, and ongoing
projects in the Northwest are described. (Wilsonweb)
LaDuke,
W (1996). “Like tributaries to a river: the growing strength of native
environmentalism.” Sierra 81(6): 38(38).
Norton,
J, R Pawluk, et al. (1996). “Observation and experience linking science and
indigenous knowledge at Zuni, New Mexico.” Journal of Arid Environments
39(2): 331-340.
Ancient agricultural societies
farming the same soils for centuries offer alternative knowledge for combating
desertification. The resulting agriculture is sustainable as well as culturally
and environmentally appropriate. This paper describes an approach to enabling
one such system at the Zuni Indian Reservation, New Mexico. The approach links
agroecology and ethnoscience research to grassroots community action.
Agroecology research has revealed enhanced soil quality in traditional runoff
agricultural fields, while ethnoscience shows a subtle understanding of local
soils and geomorphology. The research supports community action by recognizing
and valuing a local agricultural system so that solutions to land degradation
can build on indigenous knowledge. (C)1998 Academic Press Limited.
Notzke,
C (1995). “A new perspective in aboriginal natural resource management:
comanagement.” Geoforum 26(2): 187-209.
Co-management is a recurrent
theme of growing importance in the management of renewable resources in Canada,
particularly where aboriginal and non-aboriginal people are interested in
utilizing these resources. 'Co-management' broadly refers to the sharing of
power and responsibility between government and local resource users. This is
achieved by various levels of integration of local and state level management
systems. In practice there is a wide spectrum of co-management arrangements,
ranging from the tokenism of local participation in government research to
local communities retaining substantial self-management power. Comanagement
regimes may be area-specific, or they may be focused on one particular species.
Co-management regimes for renewable resources between aboriginal and
non-aboriginal parties are being established in all parts of Canada under widely
varying circumstances and for different purposes. One of the most important
vehicles for the establishment of co-management regimes is the settlement of
comprehensive aboriginal claims, which usually involves exclusive and/or
preferential harvesting rights for aboriginal people on Crown lands within
their claim territory and their involvement in the management of these
resources. Other comanagement regimes are initiated by government in response
to a perceived or real resource crisis, or by aboriginal groups as a means of
conflict resolution and to protect treaty and aboriginal rights. More recently
co-management has also been adopted by provincial governments as a tangible
expression of a fundamental rethinking of
rights and relationships. Not surprisingly, the success rate of
comanagement schemes varies. The integration and mutual accommodation of such
dissimilar entities as the indigenous and state systems of resource management
in any form of co-management is an extremely
complicated and potentially frustrating process. Nevertheless, this
route has assisted aboriginal people in Canada in regaining considerable
influence over the management of resources they depend upon. Furthermore, there
is a distinct possibility that down the road of political evolution
co-management of natural resources will be
recognized as a constitutionally entrenched right of aboriginal people.
(Source)
Ohmagari,
K and F Berkes (1997). “Transmission of indigenous knowledge and bush skills
among the Western James Bay Cree women of subarctic Canada.” Human Ecology
25(2): 197-222.
The transmission of 93 items of
women's indigenous knowledge and bush skills was studied in two subarctic
Omushkego (West Main) Cree Indian communities, Moose Factory and Peawanuck,
Ontario, Canada. About half of all bush skills were still being transmitted at
the ''hands-on'' learning stage. Some skills such as setting snares and
fishnets, beadwork, smoking geese, and tanning moose and caribou hides were
transmitted well. Many skills no longer essential for livelihoods, such as some
fur preparation skills and food preservation techniques, were not. Loss of
certain skills and incomplete transmission of others (a lower level of mastery
than in older generations) were attributable to changes in the educational
environment. diminished time available in the bush, problems related to
learning bush skills at later ages, and changes in value systems. These factors
seemed to impair the traditional mode of education based on participant
observation and apprenticeship in the bush, which provided the essential
self-disciplining educational environment. Policy measures to counteract these
trends may include the institution
of a
hunters' income security program to provide incentives for family units to go
on the land, rather than all-male hunting parties. (SSCI)
Reid,
TS and DD Murphy (1995). “Providing a regional context for local conservation
action.” BioScience 45: S 84-S 90.
Part of a special supplement on science and biodiversity policy.
California's coastal sage scrub community represents the first trial of the
National Community Conservation Planning program. This program entails the application of present day tools of
conservation biology to local land use planning. It integrates conservation and planning to link social and
economic considerations to biological concerns. Land ownership and conservation
planning and the Natural Community Planning Act of 1991 are discussed. In addition, the planning challenges, planning
approaches, and conservation guidelines used in the sage scrub community
project are outlined, as is the current status of the program. (Source)
Reimer,
G (1993). “'Community-based' as a culturally appropriate concept of
development: a case study from Pangnirtung, Northwest Territories.” Culture
13(2): 67-74.
Schwab,
J (1994). Deeper shades of green: the rise of blue-collar and minority
environmentalism in America. San Francisco, Sierra Club Books.
Somma,
M and S Tolleson-Rinehart (1997). “Tracking the elusive green women: sex,
environmentalism, and feminism in the United States and Europe.” Political
Research Quarterly 50: 153-169.
AGRICULTURE:
Chapeskie,
AJ (1990). “Indigenous law, state law and the management of natural resources:
wild rice and the Wabigoon Lake Ojibway Nation.” Law and Anthropology 5:
129-166.
FOREST:
Brightman,
RA (1987). Conservation and resource depletion: the case of the boreal forest
Algonquians. in The Question of The Commons. B McCay and J Acheson, Ed.
Tucson, University of Arizona Press:
121-141.
Dumont,
CW, Jr (1996). “The demise of community and ecology in the Pacific Northwest:
historical roots of the ancient forest conflict.” Sociological Perspectives
39: 277-300.
Part of a special issue on environmental conflict in the U.S. The writer discusses the economic and
ecological crises in the Pacific Northwest that have come about as a result of
the loss of 90 percent of the region's ancient, or "old growth,"
forests. A description of the sense of community
and cultural heritage that is being lost in the small, timber dependent
communities in the region a social
crisis that has resulted from the ecological and economic crises is provided. It is concluded that all of these crises should be comprehended
as resulting from the economic, political, and historical circumstances that
facilitated the emergence of the wealthiest and biggest timber ownership.
(Journal)
Fortmann,
L and J Kusel (1990). “New voices, old beliefs: forest environmentalism among
new and long-standing rural residents.” Rural Sociology 55(2): 214.
Hansis,
R (1998). “A political ecology of picking: non-timber forest products in the
Pacific Northwest.” Human Ecology 26(1): 67-86.
Using a political ecology
framework this research analyzes the recent entry of recent Latino and Southeast
Asian immigrants into the harvesting of non-timber forest products in the
Pacific Northwest. Using both permit data and interviewing, it suggests that a
world market for these products, government policy, and environmental
conditions have the potential for driving harvests to unsustainable levels and
exacerbating incipient conflicts. (Journal)
Huntsinger
and McCaffrey (1995). “ A forest for the trees: Forest management and the Yurok
environment.” American Indian Culture and Research Journal 19: 155-192.
Machlis,
GE and JE Force (1988). “Community stability and timber-dependent communities.”
Rural Sociology 53(2): 220.
Pavel,
DM, MJ Pavel, et al. (1993). “Too long, too silent: the threat to cedar and the
sacred ways of the Skokomish.” American Indian Culture and Research Journal
17(3): 53-80.
Pierre,
YL (1994). “Illicit harvest.” National Parks 68(5-6): 33.
Richards,
R and M Creasy (1997). “Ethnic diversity, resource values, and ecosystem
management: Matsutake mushroom harvesting in the Klamath bioregion.” Society
and Natural Resources 9(4): 359-374.
Values attached to natural
resources by cultural groups are often overlooked in defining the goals of
ecosystem management. Resource values may be especially important when groups
compete not only for the use but also the cultural meaning of a common
resource. When groups increasingly differ in ethnicity and marginality, the
resource values which they attach to that common resource may diverge
sharply. As a result, ecosystem
management goals may not adequately address the concerns of different ethnic
groups who use a natural resource. This is the case with special forest
products, an understudied component of ecosystem management. We examined the
role of resource values and resource competition in special forest product
harvesting in this investigation of North American matsutake or tanoak mushroom
(Tricholoma magnivelare) collection in national forests in the Klamath
bioregion. Data obtained through picker surveys, field interviews, and analysis
of mushroom permits indicated that different ethnic groups varied in their
harvesting experience, harvesting patterns, means of resource control, and
resource values. These variations stemmed from competing resource use and
diverging resource values and revealed how ethnic diversity contributes to
resource conflicts and affects forest sustainability. (Source)
Satterfield,
T (1997). “"Voodoo Science" and common sense: ways of knowing
old-growth forests.” Journal of Anthropological Research 53(443-459).
Willems
Braun, B (1997). “Buried epistemologies: the politics of nature in (post)
colonial British Columbia.” Annals
of the Association of American Geographers
87: 3-31.
The writer seeks to explore modern representations of the
"rainforest" and "nature" in the Clayoquot Sound region of
British Columbia, Canada, and traces a series of "buried
epistemologies" through which neocolonial relations are asserted in the
region. He examines the emergence of
"nature" as a discrete and separate object of aesthetic reflection,
scientific inquiry, and political and economic calculations at specific sites
and specific historical moments. He
argues that although the concept of nature is invested with, and embedded in,
social histories, the "forest" has recently been constructed as a
realm separate from "culture" and relocated within the abstract
spaces of the market, the nation, and the biosphere and global community. He contends that colonialist practices and
rhetorics are present but unthought in many of the categories, identities, and
representational practices used today in both public debate and scientific
management of "natural landscape" and "natural resources."
(Source)
LAND TENURE/PROPERTY RIGHTS/COMMONS:
Berkes,
F (1987). Common-property resource management and Cree Indian fisheries in
subarctic Canada. in The Question of the Commons. B McCay and J Acheson,
Ed. Tucson, University of Arizona Press: 66-91.
Feld, S
and K Basso, Eds. (1996). Senses of Place. Albuquerque, School of
American Research.
Marchand,
ME and R Winchell (1992). “Tribal implementation of GIS: a case study of
planning applications with the Colville Confederated Tribes.” American
Indian Culture and Research Journal 16(4): 175-183.
MARINE/FISHERIES:
Acheson,
JM (1997). “Politics of managing the Maine lobster industry: 1860 to the
present.” Human Ecology 25(1): 3-27.
Marine fisheries are in a state
of crisis One of the few successfully managed fisheries is the Maine lobster
industry where catches are at an all time high. An important factor in this
success is the effectiveness of regulations which were developed during three
periods over the course of the past 125 years. In all cases, the regulations
are the result of heavy lobbying activity by various factions in the industry.
Both strong commercial rivalry and genuine concern for the well-being of the
lobster resource played a role in generating these regulations However history
did not repeat itself In each period the players, circumstances, and goals were
very different The result, however is a set of effective regulationswhich are
largely self-enforcing. (Journal)
Berkes,
F (1987). Common-property resource management and Cree Indian fisheries in
subarctic Canada. in The Question of the Commons. B McCay and J Acheson,
Ed. Tucson, University of Arizona Press: 66-91.
Doubleday,
N (1994). Arctic whales: sustaining indigenous peoples and conserving Arctic
resources. in Elephants and Whales: Resources for Whom?Ed, Basel :
Gordon and Breach Publishers S. A.
Faegteborg,
M (1987). “Harpoon is cast - the Inuit establish a nature conservation strategy
for the Arctic.” IWGIA Newsletter 49: 3-8.
Freeman,
MMR (1997). “Issues affecting subsistence security in arctic societies.” Arctic
Anthropology 34(1): 7-17.
Huntington,
H (1998). “Observations on the utility of the semi-directive interview for
documenting traditional ecological knowledge.” ARCTIC 51(3): 237-242.
Traditional ecological knowledge
(TEK) offers ecological information and insight relevant to ecological
management and research that cannot be obtained from other sources. Its use is
hindered by difficulties of access, in that TEK is typically not available to a
wide audience. Documentation can overcome this obstacle, allowing TEK to be
considered with other forms of easily disseminated information. This paper
describes the author's experience using the semi-directive interview to
document TEK about beluga whales inAlaska. This method allows the participants
as well as the researcher to guide the interview, so that associations made by
the participant, and not just those anticipated by the researcher, are
discussed. Using maps as the starting point for discussions with individuals or
groups, the interviews covered expected topics, such as migration and feeding
behavior, as well as unanticipated topics, such as the possible influence of
beavers on beluga distribution. The primary research session was followed a
year later by a review session to verify the accuracy of the draft report, add
missing information, or remove information the publication of which might harm
community interests. The author found the semi-directive interview to be an
effective and powerful method for accurate and comprehensive documentation of
TEK. It worked especially well in group interviews, which allowed participants
to stimulate and validate each other. (Journal)
McCay,
B (1988). “Muddling through the clam beds: cooperative management of New
Jersey's hard clam spawner sanctuaries.” Journal of Shellfish Resources
7(2): 327-340.
Palmer,
C (1993). “Folk management, soft evolutionism, and fishers motives:
Implications for the regulation of the lobster fisheries of Maine and
Newfoundland.” Human Organization 52(4): 414-420.
This paper uses an examination
of the relations between indigenous management practices and formal regulations
in the lobster fisheries of Maine and Newfoundland to revise some current
assumptions about the nature of indigenous practices. It argues that many
current conceptions of indigenous practices are based on a flawed theoretical
position referred to as ''soft evolutionism'' A rejection of ''soft
evolutionism'' leads to the realization that the greatest contribution of
indigenous practices to the formation of formal regulations is not to be found
in their unintended conservative effects, but in their ability to reveal the
conscious goals and values of fishers. (Journal)
Pinkerton,
E (1987). Intercepting the state: dramatic processes in the assertion of local
co-management rights. in The Question of the Commons. B McCay and J
Acheson, Ed. Tucson, University of
Arizona Press: 344-369.
Robinson,
GM (1997). “Community-based planning: Canada's Atlantic Coastal Action Program
(ACAP).” The Geographical Journal 163(1): 25-38.
The Atlantic Coastal Action
Program (ACAP) was established in 1991 by Environment Canada in Canada's four
Atlantic provinces. Focusing on 13 designated areas, ACAP depends largely upon strong participation of local
residents to manage coastal resources, as it attempts to build 'bottom-up'
initiatives through the formation of stakeholder committees comprising a
cross-section of community residents, local government officials and
representatives from local businesses and academia. This paper reports the
preliminary findings of research on ACAP, examining the growth of community participation
in the Program and analysing the general development of the scheme. It
concentrates primarily on three rural
localities designated under ACAP, reporting interviews with local residents and
analysing impacts upon local
communities. It is suggested that, although
participation in and awareness of the scheme by local residents is
relatively limited, the groundwork has been laid for both more extensive
community involvement and for further development of significant practical
attempts to improve the quality of the environment. Much will depend on
availability of funds once the 13 ACAP groups have prepared environmental
management plans during 1996. (Wilsonweb)
PASTORAL:
Kvist,
R (1991). “Saami reindeer pastoralism as an indigenous resource management
system: the case of Tuorpon and Sirkas, 1760-1860.” Arctic Anthropology
28(2): 121-134.
PROTECTED AREA:
Harris,
L (1997). “Urban neighbors' wildlife-related attitudes and behaviors near
federally protected areas in Tucson, Arizona.” Natural Areas Journal 17:
144-148.
Results of a 1990 mail survey of
577 households living within one mile of the Pusch Ridge Wilderness and Saguaro
National Park; recommends community relations tactics for wilderness area managers. (Source)
Huntsinger,
L (1998). “ Science and ecosystem management in the national parks.” Society and Natural Resources 11(2): 196-
198.
Keiter,
R (1997). “Preserving nature in the national parks: law, policy, and science in
a dynamic environment.” Denver
University Law Review 74(3): 649-695.
Machlis,
GE (1989). Managing parks as human ecosystems. in Public Places and Public
Spaces. I Altman and E Zube, Ed. New York, Plenum Press: 255-275.
Machlis,
GE (1995). Social science and protected area management: the principles of
partnership. in Expanding Partnerships in Conservation. JA McNeely, Ed.
Washington DC, Island Press.
Overton,
J (1979). “A critical examination of the establishment of national parks and
tourism in underdeveloped areas: Gros Morne National Park in Newfoundland.” Antipode
11(2): 34-47.
SoleckiI,
WD (1994). “Putting the biosphere reserve concept into practice - some evidence
of impacts in rural communities in the United-States.” Environmental Conservation 21(3): 242-
247.
This paper examines some of the impacts of Biosphere Reserve planning on the socio-economic conditions
of rural communities in the United States. Through a review of the literature,
it is argued that three broad types of problems can develop when Biosphere Reserve plans are put into
effect. These include unexpected development shifts, shifts in the distribution
of benefits and costs of economic development, and a loss of local governments' ability to provide public
services. Though Biosphere Reserve planning has been cast as a strategy for experimentation in community and
ecological sustainability, the planning and management process itself causes
paradoxical local impacts. It is argued that problems resulting from Biosphere Reserve planning are similar to problems
resulting from other types of land-use planning in developed countries.
Several broad suggestions are offered
for responding to these issues. They include an increased socio-historical
appreciation among planners of the current conditions of rural communities, and
an increase in evaluation research on the impacts of Biosphere Reserve management strategies. (Source)
Vance,
L (1998). “National parks and the women's voice: A history.” American
Historical Review 103(2): 609- 610.
White,
D (1993). “Tourism as economic development for native people living in the
shadow of a protected area: a North American case study.” Society and
Natural Resources 6(4): 339-345.
This article is a case study
about the economic feasibility of a tourist development project on the
Havasupai Reservation in Northern Arizona, which borders the Grand Canyon
National Park. The central issue addressed is the merits of promoting tourism
as a means of economic development for a native population living in or next to
a protected area. The case study supports many insights on tourist-based
development prevalent in the literature, particularly the importance of
Havasupai control of tourist development. The case study also attests to the
complexity of tourism as an economic development strategy, identifying some of
the trade-offs associated with tourism on that Havasupai Reservation. In so
doing, the paper discusses the limitations of economic analysis, for many of
these trade-offs cannot be expressed in monetary terms. The major lesson of the
case study, however, is that rigorous analytical economic analysis of
individual development projects is essential. While economic analyses are
severely limited in scope, such analyses can help local people evaluate some of
the trade-offs associated with tourism, and lead to better decisions about the
appropriate scale and extent of tourist development. (Source)
WILDLIFE:
Crum, R
(1997). “Healing the spirit: Indian tribes in the U.S. are raising bison, not
only for food, but for spiritual sustenance.” Wildlife Conservation
100 Mar./Apr.: 36-43.
The InterTribal Bison Cooperative (ITBC) is restoring bison herds
on reservation lands and simultaneously reclaiming Native American
culture. The great herds of bison were
destroyed during the Indian Wars of the last century by a federal government
and military command that recognized the importance of the animal to native
life. Since the ITBC involving 40 tribes from 17 states began its work in 1991, its bison population
has been boosted to over 8,000 animals and half a million acres have been
dedicated to the project. The
cooperative seeks to restore the entire habitat and to redirect community
structure around the bison. Although
ostensibly the management system appears to be a mix of multiple use and
wilderness, these concepts are alien to Native Americans, who see all land as
sacred and with potential for use. (Wilsonweb)
Doubleday,
N (1994). Arctic whales: sustaining indigenous peoples and conserving Arctic
resources. in Elephants and Whales: Resources for Whom?Ed, Basel :
Gordon and Breach Publishers S. A.
Franklin,
TM (1997). “WIN: support for wildlife management.” Wildlife Society Bulletin 25 Fall: 745-746.
The Wildlife Society is establishing the Wildlife Information
Network (WIN) to address the need for outreach to a wider community of wildlife
enthusiasts. The WIN will authorize the
chapters, student chapters, and individual members of the society to start up
cooperative projects with landowners, groups, and businesses to improve
conditions for wildlife by enhancing habitat quality and increasing
recreational opportunities. The program
will provide wildlife professionals with training that will allow them to
provide solutions to apparent conflicts between resource users and to promote
improved relations with businesses endeavoring to exercise an ethic of natural
resource stewardship on their land. The
WIN program is receiving a challenge grant from the National Fish and Wildlife
Foundation, in addition to matching grants from farming, forestry, and conservation
groups. (Wilsonweb)
Howard,
WW (1995/6). “Asking people first.” National Wildlife 34
Dec.: 6.
The National Wildlife Federation
(NWF) has come up with a plan to replace the Endangered Species Act (ESA) with
a revised law that increases citizen involvement in the decision making
process. It proposes to replace Habitat
Conservation Planning, currently a cumbersome process for deciding how to save
a species in its habitat, with Community Based Recovery Planning, which will
give communities a larger say in how the ESA is implemented. In addition, the NWF plan recommends the
establishment of multispecies recovery plans and proposes a system that
prevents endangerment of plant and animal species on public lands. (Wilsonweb)
Kellert,
S (1984). “Urban American perceptions and uses of animals and the natural
environment.” Urban Ecology 8: 209-228.
Kvist,
R (1991). “Saami reindeer pastoralism as an indigenous resource management
system: the case of Tuorpon and Sirkas, 1760-1860.” Arctic Anthropology
28(2): 121-134.
Osherenko,
G (1988). “Can co-management save Arctic wildlife?” Environment 30(6):
6-13.